Work management · replacement recipe

Go from Asana to Trello

The job: A single team work-tracking process (Tasks, Owners, Statuses, Due dates, A few reports). Pick where you are today and where you want to land; the move below follows your pick.

From · what you pay for now
Asana
Asana Starter, 10 seats · $110/mo
Year one+$919modeled
To · your pickBest fit
Trello
Free plan · $0 a month
Change where you land

The money

$110/mo today , then $0/mo

Asana Starter, 10 seats

Year one, net+$919
Pays back in3.6 months

Modeled from public list prices, with your time at $50 an hour. Show the math

Does it do the job? 5 of 5 covered

  • Covered: Tasks
  • Covered: Owners
  • Covered: Statuses
  • Covered: Due dates
  • Covered: A few reports

The work

Setup
About 8 h
Upkeep
None
Watch out
No timeline, dashboards or table views on Free (Premium); 250 Workspace command runs a month…

Make the move in four steps

  1. Export from Asana

    A project, a saved search or My tasks. Format: CSV or JSON

    Export steps
  2. Set up Trello

    Up to 10 people; tasks with owners, statuses and due dates on at most 10 boards, 250 automation runs a month

    Details
  3. Switch links and integrations

    Point links, embeds and integrations at Trello, then send a test through every one.

  4. Cancel Asana

    Turn off renewal before your renewal date, once the new setup works. Access runs until: The end of the current billing period (the next renewal date).

    How to cancel Asana
Open TrelloHow to cancel Asana
Modeled, not measured. Savings use public prices and planning assumptions: the bill you stop paying, minus the new tool, your upkeep time and your setup time at $50/hour, over the first 12 months. Paths marked Tested by Stackcut were run end to end by us on our own products. They're our tests, not customer results. Check the must-haves in each recipe before you switch.

The whole recipe: 7 ways out, best first

What you use

  • Tasks
  • Owners
  • Statuses
  • Due dates
  • A few reports

Not covered

  • Full portfolio planning
  • Universal dependency engine
  • All integrations
  • Full collaboration parity

Check before switching

  • Team agrees to narrower workflow
  • Dependencies preserved
  • Training cost counted
  • Free/downgraded tier checked

Agents: get_recipe("work-tracker") on the Stackcut MCP server.

7 ways out, best first

Switch vendorTrello FreeSaves $919 in year one
$110/mo today → $0/mo · setup 8 h · then $1,319/yr · payback 3.6 mo
Up to 10 people; tasks with owners, statuses and due dates on at most 10 boards, 250 automation runs a month
Covers 100% of the core features
Baseline Asana Starter $10.99/user/month billed yearly for 10 users. Trello Free is $0 for up to 10 collaborators and 10 boards per Workspace; an 11th person or board means Trello Standard at $5/user/month billed yearly, still about half of Asana Starter.
How we got this
You pay now: Asana Starter$10.99/user/mo × 10 users$110/mo
New cost: Trello Freefree plan$0/mo
Difference each month$110 − $0+$110/mo
Over 12 months+$110 × 12+$1,319
Setup, once8 h × $50/h−$400
Year one+$1,319 − $400+$919
  • Not counting your time (8 h in year one): saves $1,319 in year one.

Year one = 12 × (what you pay now − the new cost − upkeep) − setup, with your time at $50/hour. Prices are public list prices; hours are Stackcut’s planning estimates. Price it for your team

Switch vendorPlane (free tier)Saves $112 in year one
$13.49/mo today → $0/mo · setup 1 h · then $162/yr · payback 3.7 mo
If your use fits the free tier (Free cloud plan: up to 12 users).
Covers 100% of the core features
Plane is open source (AGPL-3.0), and its cloud Free plan covers up to 12 users with boards, cycles and pages.
How we got this
You pay now: Asana Starter$13.49/user/mo × 1 user$13.49/mo
New cost: Plane (free tier)free plan$0/mo
Difference each month$13.49 − $0+$13.49/mo
Over 12 months+$13.49 × 12+$162
Setup, once1 h × $50/h−$50
Year one+$162 − $50+$112
  • Not counting your time (1 h in year one): saves $162 in year one.

Year one = 12 × (what you pay now − the new cost − upkeep) − setup, with your time at $50/hour. Prices are public list prices; hours are Stackcut’s planning estimates. Price it for your team

Switch vendorClickUp UnlimitedSaves $79 in year one
$110/mo today → $70/mo · setup 8 h · then $479/yr · payback 10 mo
10 users; tasks, owners, statuses, due dates, list/board/calendar views and a few dashboards
Covers 100% of the core features
Baseline Asana Starter $10.99/user/month billed yearly; ClickUp Unlimited $7/user/month billed yearly. Both scale per user, so the saving is about $4 per user per month; on these assumptions year one pays back from 9 users.
How we got this
You pay now: Asana Starter$10.99/user/mo × 10 users$110/mo
New cost: ClickUp Unlimited$7/user/mo × 10 users$70/mo
Difference each month$110 − $70+$39.90/mo
Over 12 months+$39.90 × 12+$479
Setup, once8 h × $50/h−$400
Year one+$479 − $400+$79
  • Not counting your time (8 h in year one): saves $479 in year one.

Year one = 12 × (what you pay now − the new cost − upkeep) − setup, with your time at $50/hour. Prices are public list prices; hours are Stackcut’s planning estimates. Price it for your team

Agent skillMCP server: Backlog.mdCosts $238 more in year one
$13.49/mo today → $0/mo + 0.5 h upkeep · setup 2 h
Team task tracking as Markdown files in your Git repo that coding agents read and update, instead of a work-management seat.
Covers 60% of the core features (not: Due dates, A few reports)
Assumes you already pay for an agent that runs skills (Git; any agent (CLI or MCP)); that agent's cost isn't counted. Setup (2 h) and upkeep (0.5 h a month) are Stackcut's estimates; not tested by Stackcut.
License: MIT
Install: npm i -g backlog.md && backlog init (see README for the MCP setup)
How we got this
You pay now: Asana Starter$13.49/user/mo × 1 user$13.49/mo
New cost: MCP server: Backlog.mdruns in the agent you already pay for$0/mo
Your upkeep time0.5 h/mo × $50/h$25/mo
Difference each month$13.49 − $0 − $25−$11.51/mo
Over 12 months−$11.51 × 12−$138
Setup, once2 h × $50/h−$100
Year one−$138 − $100−$238
  • Not counting your time (8 h in year one): saves $162 in year one.

Year one = 12 × (what you pay now − the new cost − upkeep) − setup, with your time at $50/hour. Prices are public list prices; hours are Stackcut’s planning estimates. Price it for your team

Replace with AIReplace with AI: team work trackerCosts $421 more in year one
$110/mo today → $20/mo + 1 h upkeep · setup 16 h + $100 · then $479/yr · payback 22.6 mo
10 users; one team's workflow: tasks, owners, statuses, due dates and a few saved reports
Covers 100% of the core features
Flat $20/month hosting plus an hour of upkeep a month against Asana Starter at $10.99 per user: it saves money every month from 7 users but only pays back its setup within the first year from 14 users. Below that, Trello Free (up to 10 people) or ClickUp Unlimited is cheaper.
How we got this
You pay now: Asana Starter$10.99/user/mo × 10 users$110/mo
New cost: Replace with AI: team work trackerhosting and API costs (modeled)$20/mo
Your upkeep time1 h/mo × $50/h$50/mo
Difference each month$110 − $20 − $50+$39.90/mo
Over 12 months+$39.90 × 12+$479
Setup, once16 h × $50/h + $100 one-time−$900
Year one+$479 − $900−$421
  • Not counting your time (28 h in year one): saves $979 in year one.

Year one = 12 × (what you pay now − the new cost − upkeep) − setup, with your time at $50/hour. Prices are public list prices; hours are Stackcut’s planning estimates. Price it for your team

Sources: asana.com
Open sourceWeKanCosts $1,298 more in year one
$13.49/mo today → $5/mo + 2 h upkeep · setup 4 h
Covers 100% of the core features
MIT-licensed kanban boards with cards, due dates, labels and checklists; self-host free.
License: open_source
How we got this
You pay now: Asana Starter$13.49/user/mo × 1 user$13.49/mo
New cost: WeKana small server (modeled)$5/mo
Your upkeep time2 h/mo × $50/h$100/mo
Difference each month$13.49 − $5 − $100−$91.51/mo
Over 12 months−$91.51 × 12−$1,098
Setup, once4 h × $50/h−$200
Year one−$1,098 − $200−$1,298
  • Not counting your time (28 h in year one): saves $102 in year one.

Year one = 12 × (what you pay now − the new cost − upkeep) − setup, with your time at $50/hour. Prices are public list prices; hours are Stackcut’s planning estimates. Price it for your team

Open sourceBaserowSavings not modeled yet
Covers 100% of the core features
License: MIT for non-premium/non-enterprise core per official repository; paid editions have separate terms. https://github.com/baserow/baserow
Sources: baserow.io

Compare before you switch

Read the checked comparisons and workload guides for the tools this recipe replaces.

All 139 recipes · Savings leaderboard · Every vendor, with prices and cancel steps