Courses · replacement recipe

Go from Thinkific to Payhip

The job: Course platform (Courses, quizzes and discussions, Checkout and Thinkific Payments, Site builder and landing pages). Pick where you are today and where you want to land; the move below follows your pick.

From · what you pay for now
Thinkific
Thinkific Start · $109/mo
Year one+$1,258modeled
To · your pickBest fit
Payhip
Free plan · $0 a month
Change where you land

The money

$109/mo today , then $0/mo

Thinkific Start

Year one, net+$1,258
Pays back in0.5 months

Modeled from public list prices, with your time at $50 an hour. Show the math

Does it do the job? 3 of 3 covered

  • Covered: Courses, quizzes and discussions
  • Covered: Checkout and Thinkific Payments
  • Covered: Site builder and landing pages

The work

Setup
About 1 h
Upkeep
None
Watch out
Check first: You only rely on: Courses, quizzes and discussions, Checkout and Thinkific Payments, Site builder and landing pages

Make the move in four steps

  1. Export from Thinkific

    User report (students and other users, with sign-up custom-field answers). Format: CSV

    Export steps
  2. Set up Payhip

    Solo creators: courses with certificates, memberships and downloads on Payhip's free plan for 5% plus processing; no community.

    Details
  3. Switch links and integrations

    Point links, embeds and integrations at Payhip, then send a test through every one.

  4. Cancel Thinkific

    Turn off renewal before your renewal date, once the new setup works. Access runs until: The end of the billing cycle for paid features; add-ons end immediately.

    How to cancel Thinkific
Open PayhipHow to cancel Thinkific
Modeled, not measured. Savings use public prices and planning assumptions: the bill you stop paying, minus the new tool, your upkeep time and your setup time at $50/hour, over the first 12 months. Paths marked Tested by Stackcut were run end to end by us on our own products. They're our tests, not customer results. Check the must-haves in each recipe before you switch.

The whole recipe: 3 ways out, best first

What you use

  • Courses, quizzes and discussions
  • Checkout and Thinkific Payments
  • Site builder and landing pages

Not covered

  • Community
  • Digital downloads
  • Coaching and webinars
  • Memberships and subscriptions
  • Completion certificates

Check before switching

  • You only rely on: Courses, quizzes and discussions, Checkout and Thinkific Payments, Site builder and landing pages
  • Export your data from Thinkific before canceling

Agents: get_recipe("replace-thinkific") on the Stackcut MCP server.

3 ways out, best first

Switch vendorPayhip (free tier)Saves $1,258 in year one
$109/mo today → $0/mo · setup 1 h · then $1,308/yr · payback 0.5 mo
If your use fits the free tier (Free Forever: all features, unlimited products and revenue, 5% transaction fee; PayPal and Stripe charge their standard processing on top).
Covers 100% of the core features
Solo creators: courses with certificates, memberships and downloads on Payhip's free plan for 5% plus processing; no community.
How we got this
You pay now: Thinkific Startflat price$109/mo
New cost: Payhip (free tier)free plan$0/mo
Difference each month$109 − $0+$109/mo
Over 12 months+$109 × 12+$1,308
Setup, once1 h × $50/h−$50
Year one+$1,308 − $50+$1,258
  • Not counting your time (1 h in year one): saves $1,308 in year one.

Year one = 12 × (what you pay now − the new cost − upkeep) − setup, with your time at $50/hour. Prices are public list prices; hours are Stackcut’s planning estimates. Price it for your team

Switch vendorTeachableSaves $190 in year one
$109/mo today → $89/mo · setup 1 h · then $240/yr · payback 2.5 mo
Covers 100% of the core features
Up to 10 published products with community, memberships and email marketing for $89/month; certificates need Teachable Growth.
How we got this
You pay now: Thinkific Startflat price$109/mo
New cost: TeachableBuilder plan$89/mo
Difference each month$109 − $89+$20/mo
Over 12 months+$20 × 12+$240
Setup, once1 h × $50/h−$50
Year one+$240 − $50+$190
  • Not counting your time (1 h in year one): saves $240 in year one.

Year one = 12 × (what you pay now − the new cost − upkeep) − setup, with your time at $50/hour. Prices are public list prices; hours are Stackcut’s planning estimates. Price it for your team

Switch vendorPodiaSaves $70 in year one
$109/mo today → $99/mo · setup 1 h · then $120/yr · payback 5 mo
Covers 100% of the core features
Creators who also want email marketing and a website: $99/month with no Podia fee (Stripe or PayPal processing applies); no course certificates listed.
How we got this
You pay now: Thinkific Startflat price$109/mo
New cost: PodiaShaker plan$99/mo
Difference each month$109 − $99+$10/mo
Over 12 months+$10 × 12+$120
Setup, once1 h × $50/h−$50
Year one+$120 − $50+$70
  • Not counting your time (1 h in year one): saves $120 in year one.

Year one = 12 × (what you pay now − the new cost − upkeep) − setup, with your time at $50/hour. Prices are public list prices; hours are Stackcut’s planning estimates. Price it for your team

More Courses recipes

All 139 recipes · Savings leaderboard · Every vendor, with prices and cancel steps